Thursday, September 25, 2008

No one has done more to serve the cause of anti-Americanism than GW Bush

As George W. Bush nears the end of his presidency, he leaves behind him a nation weakened by a style of governing beset by ideological blinders and incompetent leadership. This administration’s devotion to laissez-faire capitalism has, ironically enough, led to the situation this week where this same president is proposing using government intervention to bail out major Wall Street financial institutions to prevent, at best, the evaporation into thin air the wealth American individuals have accumulated over their lifetimes or, at worse, the collapse of the American economy.

Beyond these shores the old rule of uniting our friends and dividing our enemies has been turned on its head as the militarization of this country’s foreign policy has led friends to keep the U.S. at arms length and emboldened enemies as they see the U.S. weakened by stretching its armed forces too thin. Whatever one thinks of wisdom of invading Iraq, there is no question that the initial victory in toppling the dictator was squandered by lack of preparation, failure to commit necessary resources in advance, failure to plan, and failure to do the necessary political work in a timely manner. The country sunk into overlapping civil wars (Sunni v. Shiite, Shiite v. Shiite, Kurd v. Arab) resulting in misery for the Iraqi people and a drain on U.S. military manpower and treasury. Into this chaos came a band of Al Qaeda fighters thus providing the justification of the presence of U.S. forces. After years of conflict there finally appears to be some semblance of calm in Iraq but it comes a price of approximately 4 million people displaced with approximately half displaced internally in Iraq and the other half scattered throughout the Middle East. In the meantime, Pakistan deteriorates and Afghanistan teeters on the brink as Al Qaeda – the group responsible for the 9-11 attacks – run amok on the border between the two.

So much for bold leadership from our 43rd president in advancing the interests of our nation.

Timothy Garton Ash has this assessment in the Guardian:

As the two men who would succeed him train like Olympic athletes for tomorrow's foreign policy debate, pause for a moment to complete your final report on the 43rd president of the United States. What would you say?

I would sum up his two terms in four words: hubris followed by nemesis.

Remember the mood music of eight years ago. The greatest power the world has ever seen. Rome on steroids. An international system said to be unipolar, and Washington's unabashed embrace of unilateralism. The US as "Prometheus unbound", according to the neoconservative commentator Charles Krauthammer. Wall Street investment bankers bestriding the financial globe as Pentagon generals did the military globe and Harvard professors the soft power one. Masters of the universe. Personifying that hubristic moment: George Walker Bush.

And now: nemesis. The irony of the Bush years is that a man who came into office committed to both celebrating and reinforcing sovereign, unbridled national power has presided over the weakening of that power in all three dimensions: military, economic and soft. "I am not convinced we are winning it in Afghanistan," Admiral Mike Mullen, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, told a congressional committee earlier this month. Many on the ground say that's an understatement. The massive, culpable distraction of Iraq, Bush's war of choice, leaves the US - and with it the rest of the west - on the verge of losing the war of necessity. Here, resurgent in Afghanistan and Pakistan, are the jihadist enemies who attacked the US on September 11 2001. By misusing military power, Bush has weakened it.

Economically, the Bush presidency ends with a financial meltdown on a scale not seen for 70 years. The proud conservative deregulators (John McCain long among them) now oversee a partial nationalisation of the American economy that would make even a French socialist blush. A government bailout that will total close to a trillion dollars, plus the cumulative cost of the Iraq war, will push the national debt to more than $11 trillion. The flagships of Wall Street either go bust or have to be salvaged, with the help of government or foreign money. Most ordinary Americans feel poorer and less secure.

The decline in soft power - the power to attract - is also dramatic. The Pew Global Attitudes Survey has recorded a precipitous worldwide fall in favourable views of the US since 2001. The map is chequered, of course, but the distaste extends beyond policies of the Bush administration to things such as "American ways of doing business", and "American ideas about democracy". Iraq has been central to this collapse of credibility and attractiveness. When Bush denounces Russia for invading a sovereign country (Georgia), as he did again at the UN on Tuesday, a cry of "humbug" goes up around the world. Now American-style free market capitalism is taking a further hit, while some of the alternative models are looking better.


Obviously not all this mess can be blamed on Bush: he's not responsible for the epochal rise of China, nor for jihadist terrorists' long-term hatred of the west.

But a great deal of it can. At the Truman Library in Independence, Missouri, you can still see the painted glass sign that president Harry Truman placed on his desk in the oval office: The Buck Stops Here. (On the back it says: I'm From Missouri.) The buck stops there. The contrast between the president from Missouri and the president from Texas is painful. Judgment, prudence, vision, patience, honesty - every quality that the 33rd president so signally possessed, as the US remade the world after 1945, has been signally lacking in the 43rd.

Iraq, the US's greatest strategic blunder in at least 30 years, is Bush's fault. The buck stops there. And the more we learn about it, the clearer it becomes that it was pursued with a mixture of self-deception and lies. …


Something similar happened with the vertiginous unreality of hyper-leveraged Wall Street investment banking over the past decade. The financiers' motto, too, could have been "We create our own reality". Again, nemesis follows hubris as the night the day. The White House was not directly responsible for what looks like wild financial irresponsibility, but it was responsible for not supervising and regulating it - something even John McCain is now at least implicity admitting. The buck stopped there.

As for the decline in American soft power, that is something for which George Bush was directly to blame. His arrogance, his unilateralism, his insensitivity, his long-time denial of the need for urgent action on climate change: all fed directly into the plummeting credit of the US around the world. It would have been a different story with a different president.

For years now, we have seen those who hate the US abusing and burning effigies of Bush. The truth is, the anti-Americans should be building gilded monuments to him. For no one has done more to serve the cause of anti-Americanism than GW Bush. It is we who like and admire the US who should, by rights, be burning effigies. But now, at last, we live in hope of a better America.

January 20th cannot come soon enough unless, of course, it brings the swearing in of John McCain to carry on a Bush third term.


Anonymous said...

The story behind the bailout shall not be revealed for fifty years. After the records from the CIA of the current era are declassified, we will discover that the "bailout" has been caused by major CIA operation failures abroad and that the bankers who were being used to conduct some of these big dollar influence buys, got skittish and demanded hard currency.

On the political front here, it is baffling to see Obama not capitalizing on this golden opportunity. Had he come out strong against the bailout, or at least insisted that the bailout vote be delayed until after the election, he could have leveraged all of the voter resentment toward rich Wall Street robber barons into an easy victory. Instead, the Democrats are singing nearly the same bailout tune.

This clearly shows that the Citizens no longer have an advocate in Washington and that the two major Parties have been corrupted.

The only solution is several election cycles of anti-incumbency where incumbents of all parties are tossed out. THROW THE BUMS OUT! THROW THEM ALL O-U-T OUT!

Seven Star Hand said...

Hi J.T.,

There are wiser solutions available than politics, which helped to cause the current debacle. There's also much more to this unfolding story than most currently discern. Be a little patient to understand the truth and then hold their feet to the fire!

Money Karma comes home to roost !!!

This is the long awaited opportunity to finally "kill the beast" and kick all the bums out, forever. Read what I have been saying for insights into another way to manage this civilization, without money and without evil cabals running this world. The keys to a "New Earth" are wisdom and cooperation, not the fears and follies of the past.

It will soon become painfully obvious, to even the most clueless, that it will be far easier to step away from the deceptions of the past (money, religion, and politics) and finally fix our civilization so it works for everyone, not just for a self-chosen and abominably greedy few. Why should humanity struggle and suffer any longer to repay massive debts and endure great debacles created by amazingly greedy and deceptive monetary and political leaders? Are you familiar with the ancient concept of a Jubilee? It's time has come, and the power of the rich and arrogant is about to be blown away on the winds of long-overdue and irresistible change.

Here is Wisdom...